« Lisa Stone on BlogHer | Main | Prologue to an NPR interview on citizen journalism »

August 02, 2005

Plagiarism in the blogosphere

I spent an hour or so chatting with Elisa Camahort, BlogHer co-founder, on Sunday, a day after BlogHer ended. Among other things, we talked about the upswing in plagiarism on the Web. (Are bloggers doing it intentionally or are they just being lazy? Not sure.)

Elisa pointed out that several bloggers just plain stole passages from the San Francisco Chronicle writeup about BlogHer, and she asked: "What's to be done about something like this? It's just wrong! Right?"

For example, here's the lead on the Chron's story:

Blogging is supposed to be democratizing the world of information, empowering the individual.

And it is -- especially for male individuals. ... At conferences for bloggers, female writers find themselves in a very small minority, attendees say. And so, like in many social movements before this, women are gathering to do something about it.

Charlotte's Weblog begins its post this way:

Blogging is supposed to be democratizing the world of information, empowering the individual. And it is -- especially for male individuals. Half of all bloggers are women, according to surveys, yet the most popular blogs are created overwhelmingly by men. At conferences for bloggers, female writers find themselves in a very small minority, so women are gathering to do something about it.

Again, here's the Chron:

Three Bay Area bloggers -- Lisa Stone, Elisa Camahort and Jory DesJardins -- are holding a conference today in Santa Clara in an effort to raise women's prominence in the blogosphere. The BlogHer conference started with -- what else? -- a blog, where the organizers posted ideas for the event. Feedback from other bloggers quickly materialized.

The resulting event is as much about community building and sharing skills as it is about getting attention.

"This is a conference that the community built," said Camahort. For example, two rooms at the event are given over to sessions conceived, organized and run by the participants themselves. Sessions in these rooms include "Feminist Hip-Hop Bloggers," "Blogs in Academia" and "MommyBlogging."

The conference maxed out its capacity with 300 registrants, 85 percent of whom are women, the organizers said. Half of them hail from outside the Bay Area. A few will come from as far as Europe.

These women have blogged about feminism, politics, business and technology. They've blogged about their innermost thoughts, their children's antics and -- although this has caused problems for many -- their jobs.

And here's the lead from The Corner:

Three Bay Area bloggers -- Lisa Stone, Elisa Camahort and Jory DesJardins -- held a conference yesterday in Santa Clara in an effort to raise women's prominence in the blogosphere. The BlogHer conference started with -- what else? -- a blog, where the organizers posted ideas for the event. Feedback from other bloggers quickly materialized. The resulting event was as much about community building and sharing skills as it is about getting attention. ...

"This is a conference that the community built," said Camahort. For example, two rooms at the event are given over to sessions conceived, organized and run by the participants themselves. Sessions in these rooms include "Feminist Hip-Hop Bloggers," "Blogs in Academia" and "MommyBlogging."

The conference maxed out its capacity with 300 registrants, 85 percent of whom are women, the organizers said. Half of them hail from outside the Bay Area - a few came from as far as Europe.

These women have blogged about feminism, politics, business and technology. They've blogged about their innermost thoughts, their children's antics and -- although this has caused problems for many -- their jobs.

It's called original writing, people. If you borrow from someone else's writing -- whether they're a blogger, newspaper writer, whatever -- you need to attribute it.

If you can't string together some original thoughts, in your own words, then don't blog.

August 2, 2005 at 08:38 PM in Ethics | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451db1569e200e55044fa0f8833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Plagiarism in the blogosphere:

» OUTING BLOGGERS from Notes from a Teacher: Mark on Media
J.D. Lasica and Elisa Camahort out some bloggers who freely “borrowed” from a San Francisco Chronicle article for their own reports on the recently-concluded BlogHer conference. J.D. writes: It’s called original writing, people. If ... [Read More]

Tracked on Aug 2, 2005 9:15:26 PM

» Generation theft from Radio Free Blogistan
J.D. Lasica posts about a conversation with BlogHer co-organizer about blog plagiarism, and cites a few examples of people plagiarizing newspaper ledes in their blog entries about BlogHer (New Media Musings: Plagiarism in the blogosphere). How lame! Al... [Read More]

Tracked on Aug 3, 2005 3:00:01 PM

» Bloggers Lift from San Francisco Chronicle from Plagiarism Today
I’m a little late to this party, but I wanted to report that Elisa Camahort, co-founder of the Blogher conference, has discovered two bloggers that lifted portions of their reports on the conference straight from the San Francisco Chronicle̵... [Read More]

Tracked on Aug 5, 2005 5:59:32 PM

» Bloggers Lift from San Francisco Chronicle from Plagiarism Today
I’m a little late to this party, but I wanted to report that Elisa Camahort, co-founder of the Blogher conference, has discovered two bloggers that lifted portions of their reports on the conference straight from the San Francisco Chronicle̵... [Read More]

Tracked on Aug 5, 2005 6:49:46 PM

Comments

Hi JD...

I think part of the problem is that there are bloggers who do not come from academic backgrounds and are not aware of what plagarism is....also that some that *do* have college deegrees may not currently work where they are writing the old 5 page paper where they will get busted for plagarism.

Basically, some have rusty skills.

That's why, in the whole "citizen journalism" discussions, it would be nice to see it acknowledged that some people doing citizen journalism need some basic guidelines about plagarism and copyright. If these guidelines are known, they can also protect bloggers from cribbing one another's stuff without acknowledging it (as happened once to me.)

Even though some might disagree, guidlines on plagarism and copyright infringement are good things! Basic guidelines will increase the integrity of bloggers who may not be coming from journalistic or even bachelor's degree college level backgrounds and be simple refershers for those who forgot the rules.

Posted by: Tish G at Aug 3, 2005 11:58:00 AM

The university I attend has very clear guidelines as to what is and what isn't plagiarism, with good examples, which should be understandable to just about anyone. These are publicly accessible (i.e. without login) at http://startup.curtin.edu.au/study/studytrekk/strek6.html

It is good to see this issue being discussed in the blogosphere. It will help it to mature.

Posted by: Pam Rosengren at Aug 4, 2005 3:22:47 AM

Thanks for the update - I plead guilty to being tired (I am in the midst of a 12 week internship at a hospital) and not attributing the first of several linked parts of my post. I've updated the post (http://thecorner.typepad.com/bc/2005/07/blogher05_the_p.html), as well emailing the reporter with an apology.

Your role on the web is critical - thanks.

Posted by: bob c at Aug 5, 2005 8:10:26 PM

I do think that, for the most part, bloggers are both original writers and fully aware thinkers. So, I rather believe in a forgotten attribution and a lack the tag than on outrigt plagiarism.

But that is the blogosphere, isn't it? Self-correcting and extremely critic of its participants.

Posted by: Camilo at Aug 6, 2005 1:46:03 PM

Bob, anyone makes mistakes, but only the stout of heart corrects them. Congrats on that.

As for the other comments ... let's not set ourselves a lower standard than other media forms. This has nothing to do with academia (I loathe academia). It has to do with honesty -- not passing off others' words as your own. Simple as that.

Posted by: JD at Aug 7, 2005 1:33:42 AM

Hi JD,
In thinking about this, I wonder also if coding the quote so that it's indented (the social convention for quoting) is not easy for newer bloggers.

The "< ul >" and "< /ul >" and other html markup is really invisible for a lot of folks, depending on the blog publishing software. (note that this markup has spaces and quote marks that allow it to be shown in this comment.. remove them if you are actually going to use them.) Reminding people that it needs to be done, adn telling them how to do it.. would be very helpful.

However, not attributing with a link is really uncool.

Great post!
mary

Posted by: mary hodder at Aug 8, 2005 5:05:00 PM

Post a comment

(Because of spam, comments are held for approval by JD)